Why section 5 of the presidential rules is quite possibly the most loophole filled provision I have seen.

The rules state that the president can declare a state of emergency, and they can make decisions without council. The obvious safeguard is that council can overrule these decisions. But what is a decision? It is not stated, meaning that, if I understand correctly, the president could decide council cannot overturn decisions, cannot call no confidence, and theoretically the president could abolish democracy entirely. There is nothing preventing the president from touching the constitution. Additionally, to my knowledge, though council can overrule decisions they do not have a clear route to end a presidential state of emergency. A president could also declare their political rivals a threat and therefore possibly inflict punishments in a state of emergency.

There should be, at the very least, restrictions preventing the president from touching the constitution in a self declared emergency, and from doing actions against members of legislature and any other important positions in self declared emergencies. There should be restrictions against attacking political rivals via a self declared emergency as well. 

4 comments